Battle of the Nerds

Most of you out there who know me can probably guess (or have seen first-hand) that I’m a nerd. I accidentally quote Lord of the Rings too often for this to not be the case. This nerdiness often leads to an unhealthy fixation on pretty unimportant stuff, and one argument in particular has really stuck in my craw: Han Solo vs Indiana Jones. Two cult classic heroes, both portrayed by a young Harrison Ford. The battle breaks down like this:

The basics:

Indiana Jones is first and foremost a scholar. He is a professor of Archaeology, a member of the OSS, and an adventurer. He uses his deep knowledge of ancient cultures and languages to solve the mysteries of the ages. He finds treasure and puts it in museums. Essentially, he is a roguish nerd known for quippy one-liners, his fear of snakes, and getting the girl. What’s not to like?

Han Solo, on the other hand, has a less high-minded vocation. He is a smuggler and a mercenary. When we first meet him in Episode IV, he is in trouble for dropping his cargo at the first sign of the Federation. So maybe he isn’t that great at smuggling? Later joins the rebellion, develops a sense of doing what is right versus what is best for him as an individual. Is a scoundrel. Sarcastic wit. Materialist. Reluctant to help others when there is no indication that it will benefit him.

The women:


The bad things that happen to them:

The bad additions to their franchises:

(and this isn’t even counting all the animated movies!)

So Indie wins with the ladies, does the most for humanity, and manages to make even a bow-tie sexy.

Rematch? I think not:

So now I leave it to you folks- Indie or Han?

3 thoughts on “Battle of the Nerds

  1. First: EMPIRE. Han helped defeat the EMPIRE.

    Second: I don’t remember Indiana Jones EVER having a hand in saving the entire galaxy. Yes, still more impressive than finding the holy grail.

    Third: “It belongs in a museum!” is not a very compelling battle cry.

    Finally: Chewbacca, Millennium Falcon, “I know.”

    Indiana Jones is a fine fella, but Solo is the man. +1 vote for Han.

    • Alright, well argued KP. I still think that as a person, Han didn’t really add to the defeating of the EMPIRE. His main claim to fame there was piloting and making kissy-face with a princess.

      Chewbacca and the Millennium Falcon are cool and all, but don’t you think Chewie probably smelled like wet dog 3/4 of the time?

      And finally, the whole “I know” thing isn’t cool or romantic- it was mean! It was a waste of the [possibly] last moments of his life! Being badass in front of Darth Vader isn’t worth not telling a girl how you feel about her. Lame.

  2. Pingback: Manic Monday | Erin May Davis

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s